Access control enforced by presentation layer

Last revision (mm/dd/yy): //

Vulnerabilities Table of Contents

Description
Enforcing access control in the presentation layer means that the developer does not show buttons and links for functions and assets that are not authorized for the user. An attacker, however, is not constrained by the buttons and links presented, and can forge requests for those functions and assets. Forced browsing is one attack that targets this type of vulnerability.

Consequences
 * Disclosure of unauthorized assets (confidentiality)
 * Invocation of unauthorized business functions (integrity)

Exposure period
 * Design phase

Platform
 * Languages: any
 * Operating platforms: any

Required resources
 * Generally requires a user login, although not always

Severity Very high -- can result in disclosure of sensitive information or the invocation of protected business functions.

Likelihood of exploit With the source code, this vulnerability is very likely

Avoidance and mitigation Access control must be performed in the business layer, not only the presentation layer.

Discussion This vulnerability is similar in some ways to Validation performed in client, as the same security checks are performed in two places. Doing validation in the business logic, like doing validation on the server, are critical to security. However, many web applications and web services only do access control in the presentation layer, allowing an attacker to easily access unprotected functions.

Rick Factors
TBD

Examples
J2EE

//FIXME: JSP example of not showing a link

ASP.NET (C#)

//Incorrect usage example //example of using custom code to control access through the presentation //layer. This code creates a vulnerability, because the administration page //referenced in the href attribute is not protected, and a user could navigate //to it directly. if (currentUser.Role == Role.Admin) {              Response.Write("Administration Menu"); }

Related Attacks

 * Forced browsing

Related Vulnerabilities

 * Validation performed in client

Related Controls

 * Control 1
 * Control 2

Related Technical Impacts

 * Technical Impact 1
 * Technical Impact 2